Unsettledpick

Social and political turmoil doesn't have to be timely to be upsetting

By Matt Pais

Metromix
May 8, 2008

 
Critic's Rating:
3 1/2

Unsettled
Surfer dude Lior is one of the subjects in "Unsettled" (Credit: Resonance Pictures)
Unsettled
Running time:
84 minutes
Director:
Adam Hootnick
Genre:
Documentary
Overall User Rating:
0 (0 ratings)
Be the first to review
In summer 2005, now-deceased Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon determined that Israel would be a stronger, safer nation if Jews withdrew from the Gaza Strip, the small section of land over which Israel has long fought with Palestine. "Unsettled" looks at the effects of this order from the perspective of several Israeli youths: the activists in favor of the removal; those who live in Gaza and don't want to leave; and the military men and women who aren't sure where they stand but, unlike some of their comrades, follow directions and work towards evacuating fellow Jews from the area.

Big question:
Is this 2006 documentary still relevant several years later, while the violence continues?

Catch it: This is one for the time capsule, since writer-director Adam Hootnick's determined objectivity merely says, "Let's remember these events and then see what happens." It's a compelling, sympathetic and rarely seen take on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, focusing not on what divides the two but on how one nation struggles with itself to determine the best way to keep-or, rather, perhaps one day achieve some semblance of peace.

Skip it:
If you'd prefer soundtrack music a bit less obvious than Matisyahu. Though you can't help but wonder how the people on screen feel about the artist's less-than-traditional use of rap, rock and reggae to explore Jewish themes.

Bottom line:
Though the film doesn't explain how it chose its subjects—ranging from a lifeguard in Gaza to an American-born soldier—or get us particularly close to any of them, "Unsettled" does put relatable human faces to a particularly difficult and controversial moment in Israel’s history. Its snapshot may only seem more profound the more outdated it becomes.

Bonus: At one point an 8-year-old girl living in Gaza interviews her 14-year-old sister on a camera phone and asks questions like, "Why are you mad at the soldier and not the Prime Minister?" If only all on-camera interviewers were this direct!

Add a comment

You will be prompted to register or log in when posting.

Please note that by clicking on "Post Comment" you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator.

SHOWTIME LISTINGS

Movie theaters and showtimes for Unsettled in South Florida.

Narrow search by zipcode:

Check Showtimes for Unsettled

No Showtimes available

Movie reviews

Movie reviews

Catch up on recent film reviews you might have missed the first time around.