Jaymay, 'Autumn Fallin''

New York anti-folkie offers a warm vibe and smart lyrics on buzzworthy debut

By Adam McKibbin

Special to Metromix
March 10, 2008

 
Critic's Rating:
3 1/2

Jaymay, 'Autumn Fallin''
Autumn Fallin'
Release date:
March 11, 2008
Artist/Band name:
Jaymay
Record label:
Blue Note
Official Web Site:
http://jaymaymusic.com/
Backstory: Jamie Kristine Seerman was so nervous at her first open mic that she decided she needed a better performer name to help her cope. She dubbed herself “Jaymay” and became a regular—then a standout—in the New York City “anti-folk” scene that helped incubate Regina Spektor, the Moldy Peaches and Ani DiFranco.

Why you should care: Despite its narrative arc—a romance declining during a New York winter—“Autumn Fallin’” feels like a springtime album. It’s warm, accessible and likely to appeal to fans of Feist and Norah Jones, as well as to anyone who likes Regina Spektor’s voice but thinks she’s a little too weird.

Verdict: Charming if a tad precious, “Autumn Fallin’” should soundtrack many a romance (and breakup) in 2008. The melodies are simple but infectious, peaking with the stately “Blue Skies” and “Ill Willed Person.” Adventure isn’t her forte; the old-timey “Hard To Say” features some unfortunate scatting and underscores the creative gulf between Jaymay and edgier artists like Spektor. Jaymay’s best calling card may be her lyrics sheet--something she seems to acknowledge herself when she sings, “I’m winnin’ you with words because I have no other way.”

X-Factor:
Jaymay’s soft spot for storytelling spans a planned career in publishing (indefinitely postponed), a teenage addiction to Bob Dylan, and cutting her own creative teeth on self-described “stupid songs” about the family dog.

Add a comment

You will be prompted to register or log in when posting.

Please note that by clicking on "Post Comment" you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator.

More CD reviews

More CD reviews

Our critics and readers weigh in on the latest, greatest and not so greatest.